Roofer Company Insights on Nail vs. Staple Fastening
Every roof formula depends on fasteners extra than maximum householders have an understanding of. The shingles should be the visual layer, yet nails and staples quietly dictate how that roof rides out wind, warmth, and a long time of growth and contraction. I even have torn off roofs that seemed satisfactory from the flooring, most effective to discover a fastening technique under that explained the leaks and blow-offs. I actually have additionally seen modest properties resist brutal gusts as a result of a cautious installer accompanied the brand’s fastening development with the exact nails. Small selections in the palms of a roof repairer corporation echo for years after the team pulls away.

Most Roof business enterprise teams nevertheless set up shingles with nails. Staples reveal up in conversations, generally in the area, and so they have a place in specified roofing contexts. The argument plays out along lines of velocity, code compliance, keeping chronic, and settlement. But the fact is greater textured, and it merits a considerate breakdown from the vantage element of person who has laid, pulled, and inspected enormous quantities of fasteners on plywood decks in all different types of weather.
What fasteners really do on a shingle roof
A shingle is extra than a ornamental asphalt mat. The manufacturing facility embeds a fiberglass middle and coats the surface with granules, then provides a sealant strip that bonds to the shingle above it with heat from the sunlight. Fasteners clamp the shingle to the deck by the nailing region, which passes using that bolstered double layer on the shingle lap. A tremendous fastener bites into the deck, resists pull-out from wind uplift, holds in opposition t shear while shingles escalate or settlement, and avoids tearing the shingle mat.
When a fastener fails, the mode of failure things. A nail it's crooked, overdriven, or sunk into a spot among boards can lose chew. A staple it really is skewed so the crown runs at an angle to the shingle can slice the mat and create a commencing tear. Both can “high nail,” which means the installer misses the bolstered nailing quarter, which reduces holding vitality and voids warranties.
The task of a roofing friends near me otherwise you is to regulate all these variables: fastener desire, fastener materials, period, placement, and pressure. The tools, the workforce, or even the day’s humidity point in.
Nails: the trade simple for a reason
If you choose up a container of architectural shingles from any most important company and study the technical sheet, one can just about truthfully see nails precise as the advised fastener. Not just any nails, however corrosion-resistant roofing nails with a barbed or ring shank for elevated retain in wind zones, and with a minimum duration that guarantees three/4 inch penetration into the deck or simply by the deck by 1/eight inch in which codes require.
In practice, right here is what nails present. The shank concentrates force vertically with out slicing the shingle mat. The head creates a circular bearing floor that clamps, not cuts. When a nail is pushed flush, not overdriven, it seats into the shingle and deck and leaves the granules intact. Air stress settings, gun upkeep, and compressor line period all have an impact on how at all times a roof repairer organisation can in achieving that flush set.
On steep pitches and in top-wind coastal areas, we continuously bump to 6 nails per shingle. That 6th nail development in the main translates into fewer call-backs whilst fall storms arrive. I can revisit my jobs and spot shingles nevertheless locked down years later, on account that the nails have been positioned in the perfect quarter, spaced proper, and pushed to an appropriate intensity. Nails forgive mild misalignment superior than staples do. If you might be half of an inch off, a nail’s around head nonetheless makes a uniform clamp and is much less possible to create a stress riser in which tearing starts.
Another point is deck classification. Old homes routinely have 1x pass sheathing with gaps. Nails can bridge small irregularities greater than staples, partly on account that a nail’s point and shank can locate consistent bite in mixed-density boards. On ultra-modern OSB or plywood, nailed shingle roofs function predictably in case you respect fastener length, shank variety, and placement.
Staples: speed, facet circumstances, and the technical caveats
Staples use a crown that spans two legs. Roofing staples come in one-of-a-kind crown widths, leg lengths, and constituents. Historically, some crews leaned on staples since you will circulation straight away with a favorable stapler, and on mammoth, easy planes pace translates into hard work reductions. In the right arms, with crowns aligned adequately to the shingle’s nailing line, staples can carry well adequate for modest wind zones.
The key note is aligned. The crown must run perpendicular to the shingle slot and parallel to the publicity line. When the crown ends up diagonal or vertical relative to the shingle’s part, the two legs can pinch and reduce the mat. Over time, thermal cycling and uplift masses turn that pinch into a tear that runs beneath the headlap. I have pulled off roofs in the 10 to twelve year wide variety with half the sphere free wherein staples were skewed, and you'll see refreshing tears accurate on the crown.
Another exhausting truth is warranty coverage and code. Many shingle warranties right this moment require nails, and inspectors in coastal, storm-susceptible, or top wind zones are knowledgeable to seem for correct nailing. You can nevertheless discover markets where staples seem on roofs, in most cases on outbuildings or older installations, however a Roof guests devoted to long-time period performance pretty much steers users to nails for laminated shingles and so much residential pitches.
There are exceptions. On felt or artificial underlayment for the time of a dry-in, a large-crown cap staple can also be invaluable considering the plastic cap spreads load and reduces tearing whilst the underlayment billows. But that may be a various communication from fastening shingles to the deck, and cap staples are a short-term or underlayment-genuine resolution, now not a shingle fastener.
Holding power and wind functionality, not just numbers on a box
You will every now and then see lab values that compare pull-simply by resistance or lateral shear between excellent driven nails and staples. Numbers fluctuate with the aid of verify setup, however the steady takeaway is that this: nails cling comparably or improved in pull-out whilst put correctly, and they preserve the shingle mat stronger while misaligned. Staples can obtain top pull-using resistance while the crown is precisely in which it belongs and pushed flush, no longer overdriven. The hardship, every day on roofs, is that humans paintings speedy, shingles flex, and compressors differ. Nails are greater forgiving of those small deviations that accumulate across eighty bundles.
Field outcomes give a boost to the labs. After wind movements, adjusters and roofers see a sample. Roofs fastened with nails in the suitable region have fewer tab blow-offs and less creased shingles. Stapled roofs with crowns misaligned demonstrate extra partial detachments and greater leaks that start out at fastener penetrations. When a roof repairer agency near me writes a suggestion for a homestead inside of 5 miles of a full-size frame of water, we specify ring-shank nails and 6-nail patterns on all box shingles and hip and ridge, and we now have the music record to face at the back of that desire.
Installation method counts extra than brand
Nails and staples percentage a fatal flaw: they either fail whilst overdriven or underdriven. An overdriven fastener breaks the shingle surface and loses clamp drive. An underdriven fastener leaves the pinnacle proud, growing a bump that forestalls the shingle above from sealing effectively. Either mistake opens the door to wind-driven rain.
The appropriate approach starts with compressor management. On a funky morning a gun might also drive shallow, then through afternoon warm the strain creeps and your group begins crushing heads. We teach installers to check-power right into a scrap shingle on the commence of each elevation and after lunch. We additionally insist on blank gun noses and effectively sized hoses, considering that a sticky motive force can double-tap or kick the fastener sideways. On a staple gun this sideways impulse is the way you prove with a diagonal crown. On a nailer, it's miles how you get a crooked nail that scars the mat.
Placement self-discipline matters even extra. Shingle producers outline a nailing zone, many times demarcated with a line on laminated shingles. That region is not really arbitrary; below it the shingle has doubled materials and is situated at the overlap wherein fasteners flow because of more than one layers. Put the fastener too high and it clamps simply the upper sheet. Put it too low and it negative aspects exposure or water trip across the fastener.
Codes, warranties, and the risk of high-priced do-overs
Local codes in general adopt requisites from mannequin codes and company guidance. Because such a lot brand commands specify nails, enormously for laminated architectural shingles, many jurisdictions anticipate nails and may flag staples at inspection. Even if a code authentic misses it, a assurance claim down the road won't continue to exist if the roof became stapled in opposition t instructional materials. As a pragmatic be counted, that suggests a roofing employer that staples shingles is taking up liability which can boomerang years later.
I even have considered owners inherit stapled roofs after shopping for a space, then be informed at some stage in a storm claim that the producer will no longer lower back the subject material on the grounds that the fastening approach voided the assurance. A couple of thousand funds kept at setting up turned into a five-figure substitute with no warranty improve. As a roofer provider that stakes its call on referrals, we keep that pitfall wholly by way of nailing inside spec at any time when.
Material and corrosion resistance
Whether you elect nails or staples, metal composition and coating depend. Galvanized fasteners are a minimum for asphalt shingles. Hot-dipped galvanization resists corrosion larger than electro-galvanized coatings, certainly in coastal air. Stainless metallic nails prove up on cedar and in very competitive salt environments, nevertheless they value more. In a pinch, a budget fastener with thin zinc coating can rust, stain the shingle, and lose diameter over the years. Once rust chews down a shank, pull-out resistance drops and the head can pop due to the mat.
Length wishes cognizance too. In roof decks of 7/sixteen inch OSB, you prefer a fastener long satisfactory to penetrate solidly. For nails, 1 1/4 inch is fashionable for widely wide-spread shingles on commonly used decks, yet bump to at least one half of inch in the event you add thicker underlayments, if you happen to are fastening ridge caps thru dissimilar laminated layers, or should you overlay. For staples, leg period has to suit the deck’s thickness to keep inadequate penetration or blow-through. Again, the greater variable the deck and layers, the more regular nails are typically across container stipulations.
Speed, check, and the illusion of savings
Staples gained a reputation for pace. In production roofing, the clock subjects, and on monstrous tracts a staff may frame the choice around models hooked up in line with hour. If a stapler movements a touch speedier, and staples payment a bit less in line with container, you possibly can pencil out minor reductions.
In prepare, the ones financial savings evaporate should you component transform, inspection fails, wind-connected name-backs, and guaranty publicity. A good roofing institution can install nails at once with progressive coil nailers and thoughtful staging. The actual swing variable will not be the fastener, but the workforce’s exercise, the design plan, and how smartly the foreman units expectancies. If you deliver two crews equivalent homes and inform one to staple in a zone that prefers nails, the nail staff will probably end with fewer differences and superior lengthy-time period results. The expense of a name-returned eats the marginal advantage of a faster first cross.
Regional behavior and legacy roofs
In some areas, peculiarly in which older construction practices linger, you will still discover stapled shingle roofs. Many of those have been hooked up until now current brand coaching tightened or before regional climate styles added a warning call. best Roofing Contractor around me When a roof like that reaches its replacement cycle, it turns into a fingers-on lesson. As we tear off, we see loosening alongside rakes and eaves the place uplift force is strongest. The staples aren't simply loose; they've got elongated their holes. That elongation lets in micro-flow, which grinds granules and accelerates shingle put on. A sparkling nail sample on new shingles corrects those trouble instantaneously.
For homeowners in the hunt for a roofing company close to me, this is worth asking about in the time of estimates. Ask the estimator to explain how they fasten shingles, what nail category they use, what number of according to shingle, and how they handle gun depth. A legitimate, even if they name themselves a roofer provider or a complete-provider Roof business, need to have transparent solutions grounded in company recommendations and native code.
Specialty circumstances: low-slope membranes and metal
Nails versus staples is often a shingle communication, yet it touches different roof types. On some low-slope membranes, fasteners paintings using plates or bars that distribute load, and the fastening development is engineered by the membrane brand. In these methods, nails or screws pair with plates to achieve required uplift ratings. Staples do not belong there. On metal roofing, fasteners are either hidden clips with screws or exposed fasteners with washers. Again, staples usually are not element of that vocabulary. So when any person says they staple roofs, they just about for sure mean asphalt shingles or underlayments, now not membranes or metallic.
What I seek on a roof deck ahead of deciding fastener details
Before we even dump the guns, we investigate the deck. Moisture content things. Driving fasteners into a rainy OSB sheet can compress fibers such that as the panel dries, fasteners loosen barely. If the deck has high moisture, we pause and ventilate or agenda a return when situations are accurate. We additionally map out truss or rafter lines. Hitting voids between panels or sinking fasteners into break up edges reduces conserving continual notwithstanding fastener variety.
If we stumble upon ancient plank decks with gaps, we in the main overlay with 3/8 or 7/16 inch OSB to create a uniform floor. It bills time and cloth, but it offers nails regular chew and protects the shingle mat from flexing over voids. This is one of these judgment calls that separates a careful roofing corporation from a shortcut team.
Training the hand that holds the gun
You can purchase the most competitive coil nailers, however the installer’s behavior settle on your influence. We train techs to retailer the gun nose rectangular to the shingle, plant their feet to circumvent stretching throughout programs, and pace their photographs other than bump-firing blind. On bloodless days the sealant strip takes longer to switch on, so acceptable nailing will become even greater valuable. On sizzling afternoons, shingles soften and the risk of overdriving increases, fantastically on darker colorings. Adjusting strain among ninety and one hundred ten psi depending at the gun and hose size is a small tweak that pays off in constant heads.
We also have a behavior: after every square or two, a team lead lifts a random shingle and inspects the fasteners. Are they flush? Are they within the zone? Are there excessive nails? If a specific thing is off, we adjust exact then in place of finding it after a typhoon.
Common failure patterns I see and the way they hint back to fasteners
When you hear the telltale flutter of a free tab in a wind, the underlying tale is many times fastener placement or drive intensity. Another sample is diagonal creases that seem halfway up a shingle after a wind event. That crease kinds when the shingle lifts frequently in opposition to a misdriven or misaligned fastener, exceedingly a staple with a diagonal crown. Over time, that crease weakens the mat and invites granule loss and leaks.
Nail pops are any other complaint. They turn up while the deck releases its grip on the shank, most often through seasonal action or hitting a seam. A ring-shank nail reduces this chance in comparison to a easy shank. An electro-galvanized nail in a damp attic Roofing Contractor solutions can rust and pa prior to a sizzling-dipped one. These small variations in fastener preference convey up three to 5 years later, long after the staff is long gone.
The owner of a house communique: how to assessment a bid
When you assemble rates, you'll see broad spreads. Instead of racing to the bottom variety, ask pointed questions tied to fasteners and procedure. You will research more about the crew’s field from how they talk about nails than from smooth brochures.
Here is a quick record you may use for the period of these conversations.
- What nail sort, period, and coating will you operate, and what number of nails in line with shingle are frequent for my roof and wind publicity?
- How do you be certain nails are pushed flush, now not overdriven or underdriven, and the way in most cases do you look at various right through the task?
- Will you practice the shingle enterprise’s nailing pattern and location zones, and might I see a sample sheet?
- How do you cope with decking it is out of spec or has gaps, and the way does that influence fastener collection?
- What does my guaranty require on the topic of fasteners, and how do you record compliance for my statistics?
Those 5 questions cut through advertising and marketing and get at the center of expertise. A official Roof friends welcomes them and answers devoid of hedging.
Where staples still make sense
I do not banish staples from the truck. On man made underlayment, vast-crown cap staples are instant, reliable, and less detrimental than naked metallic heads. On short-term dry-ins, they shine. For tarps in publish-typhoon work or protecting ice and water look after wherein affordable roofing contractor plates are targeted, staplers earn their avert with the accurate add-ons. But for shingles, in just about each and every residential state of affairs the place warranties count number and wind can upward thrust, nails continue to be the shrewd determination.
Local local weather and attic circumstances impact the stakes
If you dwell in a slight inland weather with regular breezes and by and large tender climate, a stapled roof established completely can also continue to exist a normal cycle. Add upper winds, microbursts, or iciness storms with uplift, and the margins slim. Humid attics accelerate fastener corrosion if ventilation is bad, which makes the case for superior coatings on nails. In coastal cities, salt-weighted down air finds any weakness. A roofing friends that understands those microclimates will event fastener materials and styles in your web page as opposed to using a one-measurement frame of mind.
What it looks as if to do it right
On a properly-run task, you notice measured growth and essentially no drama. The foreman sets strain, demonstrates flush nailing on a pattern, and facets out the nailing sector to more moderen fingers. Chalk strains hold programs proper so installers will not be stretching or twisting to hit placement. Every valley, hip, and ridge receives consciousness since transition zones are where uplift concentrates. Six nails in line with shingle turned into the default in open exposures. The workforce cleans as they move so no one slips on debris and overdrives to capture a fall.
At the conclusion, the roof looks crisp no longer simply by reason of straight strains but seeing that each shingle lies flat, sealed, and quietly steady. When the first wind take a look at arrives, the roof does not rattle Portland OR Roofing Contractor or flutter. Months later, home owners do not locate tabs inside the yard. Years later, an inspection shows heads nonetheless tight and no signs and symptoms of cut mats around fasteners.
Bottom line from the field
Between nails and staples for shingle fastening, nails stay the right call for maximum properties, maximum climates, and most warranties. They are extra forgiving of small human blunders, more beneficial supported via producers, and shown after several storms. Staples have slender uses in underlayments and non permanent defense, and they call for close to-fabulous orientation to compete on maintaining vigour without unsafe the shingle.
If you're evaluating bids from a roofing business enterprise close to me or comparing a roof artisan agency out of city, listen in on how they describe fasteners. The nice crews anchor their excellent not in slogans however in info: nail style, placement, power intensity, and adherence to the shingle maker’s classes. Those picks weigh more than the emblem on the wrapper, in view that they may be the change among a roof that lasts and a roof that talks to come back on every occasion the wind shifts.
How can I maintain and extend the life of a flat roof in the Portland climate?
Regular inspections, keeping drains clear, addressing small issues promptly, and managing moss/algae are key to extending the life of a flat roof in Portland’s wet climate. Read more
How much does a roof replacement cost in Portland, OR in 2025?
The average roof replacement in Portland ranges from $10,000 to $22,000 depending on material, roof size, and complexity, with asphalt shingles averaging around $14,000. Read more
What are 5 early warning signs that your Portland home needs a roof replacement?
Look for missing or damaged shingles, sagging areas, moss/algae growth, interior leaks, and an aging roof. Early detection can save on costly repairs. Read more
What services do professional roofing companies typically provide?
Professional roofing companies offer inspections, repairs, replacements, flat and pitched roofing, ventilation upgrades, emergency leak response, and maintenance plans. Read more
How do roofing companies ensure compliance with safety standards and regulations?
Roofing companies comply with OSHA and local building codes through fall-protection, PPE use, proper training, scaffolding safety, and adherence to permitting requirements. Read more
What do customers say about Her Roofing?
Here are some of our Google reviews:
Check all reviews on our Google Maps page.
HER Roofing
Phone: (503) 946-9068
Address: 133 SE 9th Ave #113 Portland OR 97214
Contact HER Roofing today to schedule a consultation or learn more about our professional roofing services.