Auto Insurance Myths Debunked: What You Really Need to Know

Auto insurance touches your wallet, your stress levels, and how quickly you bounce back after a crash. The trouble is, much of what drivers believe about coverage and pricing is built on myths. I have sat across from families after a total loss, contractors whose personal policies left a gap with business use, and parents who thought their college student was covered when they were not. The patterns repeat. Misunderstandings cost money and delay claims. Good information, paired with the right policy, keeps you on the road and out of the weeds.

What follows is a field guide to common myths that trip up everyday drivers. I will break down what is true, what is not, and when exceptions apply. Where numbers differ by state or insurer, I will note the spread.

Myth 1: The color of your car affects your premium

If paint factored into risk, sports car owners would be easy targets. Red, black, pearl white, none of it sits on a rating factor sheet. What matters to an underwriter is the vehicle identification number, which reveals trim, engine size, body style, safety equipment, and loss data for that model. A red Honda Civic EX and a blue Honda Civic EX present the same base risk, barring declared modifications.

Where this myth sometimes feels true is with exotic models often ordered in eye catching colors. A track focused trim with a high horsepower engine costs more to insure, but the premium is tied to the model’s loss experience and repair cost, not the paint.

Myth 2: Minimum state liability limits are enough

Every state with compulsory insurance sets a floor. Many use split limits like 25,000 per person, 50,000 per accident, and 25,000 for property damage. That might cover a parking lot tap with bumper scuffs. It will not cover a three car pileup with two injured drivers and a luxury SUV that needs a quarter panel, sensors, and a suspension arm. A single moderate injury can run 40,000 to 100,000 in medical bills before physical therapy.

Once you exhaust your liability limits, the rest lands on you personally. Wages can be garnished and assets attached. The jump from minimum limits to robust coverage, such as 100,000 per person, 300,000 per accident, and 100,000 for property, often costs less per month than a streaming subscription. Pair that with an umbrella policy, which sits on top of your auto and Home Insurance liability, and you create a wide moat around your finances for a comparatively low premium.

Myth 3: Full coverage means everything is covered

Full coverage is not a policy term. People use it to mean they carry liability, plus comprehensive and collision on their car. That package still leaves gaps. Tire blowouts, aftermarket add ons not declared, custom wheels, business use, a rideshare trip without the proper endorsement, or an excluded driver can all sit outside that box. If your vehicle is stolen with thousands in tools inside, your personal Auto Insurance will not usually pay for tools used for work. You need a commercial endorsement or an inland marine policy to protect that equipment.

A better habit is to name the coverage. If you want your own car repaired after a crash you cause, that is collision. If you want protection for theft, fire, hail, and deer impacts, that is comprehensive. If you want to be made whole on a brand new car you owe more on than it is worth, that may involve gap insurance. If you carry passengers for a fee, you need rideshare or livery coverage. Saying full coverage at a counter will lead to clarifying questions, not a magic shield.

Myth 4: If I have health insurance, I do not need medical coverage on my auto policy

Your health insurance primarily covers your injuries, subject to its own coinsurance and deductibles. Personal Injury Protection or Medical Payments coverage on your auto policy pays medical costs for you and your passengers after a crash, regardless of fault, and often with no copay. In some states, PIP also provides wage loss and essential services benefits. When the unexpected happens on a Friday night and your passenger breaks a wrist, the ability to offer immediate coverage without arguing fault helps people get care faster.

Medical coverage on an auto policy is usually inexpensive in the scheme of things. If you have a high deductible health plan, it can bridge a real financial gap. The right amount varies by state, because PIP rules change a lot, so this is a good moment to ask your Insurance agency for comparative costs at several levels.

Myth 5: Older cars do not need comprehensive and collision

Dropping physical damage coverage can make sense when your car’s actual cash value falls below a threshold where the premium no longer justifies the potential payout. That threshold is personal. I have seen drivers keep comprehensive for 4 to 7 dollars per month because hail risks and deer strikes are very real in their area, and a cracked windshield with rain sensors can run 800 to 1,500 without glass coverage. Collision can be trimmed later if you can comfortably write a check to replace the vehicle out of pocket.

Before you remove coverage, get your car’s approximate depreciated value from your insurer or a respected valuation source, then compare the premium for comprehensive and collision plus your deductibles. If comprehensive costs 60 per year and you live under a canopy of oak trees, your risk math will look different than a desert commuter with covered parking.

Myth 6: My friend can borrow my car and their insurance will pay

Auto insurance follows the car first in most scenarios. If you lend your vehicle and your friend causes a crash, your policy is usually primary for damages and injuries, up to your limits. Your friend’s policy, if they carry one, may act as excess for liability. If your policy excludes that driver, there can be no coverage at all. That has led to some ugly conversations in kitchens and driveways.

If a friend constantly borrows your vehicle, put them on your policy. If a roommate without insurance occasionally uses your truck for errands, rethink those keys. Permissive use varies by state and by insurer. When in doubt, call your Insurance agency and ask how your carrier handles non household drivers.

Myth 7: Business use is automatically covered

A personal policy is written for personal use, commuting, and light incidental business. Door to door sales, real estate showings, delivering goods for a fee, and transporting clients can move you out of personal territory. Contract work tools, signage on the car, and mileage volume are red flags for a claims adjuster. Rideshare presents a special case. Most carriers require a rideshare endorsement to cover you between app pings. Without it, you can fall into a coverage gap between personal and the app’s commercial layer.

If you run a small business, ask about a business use endorsement or a commercial auto policy. An independent Insurance agency can map your operations and place the risk correctly. I have placed photographers, mobile groomers, and seasonal contractors this way so that a fender bender on a job did not drain the business.

Myth 8: My credit score has nothing to do with my premium

In many states, insurers use a credit based insurance score as one of several rating factors, along with age, garaging address, driving record, prior claims, and vehicle type. The logic from an actuarial standpoint is that credit behavior correlates with claims frequency. Some states ban or limit the practice, or forbid it for renewals but allow it for new business. Where it is allowed, the effect can be material. I have seen two similar drivers with clean records and identical cars differ 15 to 30 percent in premium because one had thin or troubled credit history.

The point is not to moralize. It is to be aware of the rules in your state and ask your carrier or agent how credit data is used. If your state bans it, that is simple. If not, good payment habits and low credit utilization can reduce price over time, and shopping with an independent Insurance agency near me style search can reveal carriers that weigh the factor differently.

Myth 9: Filing a claim always raises my rate

Not all claims are equal, and not all cause surcharges. A comprehensive claim for a hailstorm or a broken windshield often does not carry a surcharge because you were not at fault. Multiple comprehensive claims in a short span can still raise eyebrows. At fault collisions usually trigger a surcharge, which can last for three policy terms, depending on state filings and company rules. The size of the payout also matters, though even a small at fault claim can reset a clean driver discount.

Here is how I counsel people: if the damage is truly minor, below or near your deductible, consider paying out of pocket to preserve your loss free status. Keep photos, receipts, and a note of the date for your own records. If you are not sure whether to open a claim, call your agent and ask for a confidential discussion. Independent agencies do this every day and can walk through the math without alerting the carrier.

Myth 10: New cars are always more expensive to insure

Sometimes yes, often no. Newer vehicles usually carry better crash avoidance tech and more airbags, which lowers injury severity and claims frequency. That can offset higher repair costs. A modest new sedan with standard safety gear can cost less to insure than a ten year old sports coupe with a high loss history. Conversely, new luxury vehicles with complex sensors in bumpers and windshields can be expensive to fix. Replacing a windshield with heads up display and rain sensors can cost over 1,200, which shows up in comprehensive claim costs for that model.

Ask your Insurance agency for quotes on the finalists before you buy. Dealers know monthly car payments to the dollar. You should know the monthly insurance cost with the same precision.

Myth 11: Gap insurance is only for leases

Gap coverage pays the difference between the car’s actual cash value and the amount you still owe if the vehicle is totaled. Leases often require it, which is why people equate the two. But many financed purchases benefit from gap during the first years, especially with small down payments or longer loan terms. Cars depreciate fastest early in ownership. If you finance with 0 down over 72 months, a total loss in month 12 can leave a 2,000 to 6,000 hole between payout and payoff.

You can buy gap from the dealer or from many carriers. Auto insurers tend to price it competitively, and you can remove it once the loan balance dips below value. That is another time to call your Insurance agency for a quick check.

Myth 12: Loyalty guarantees the best rate

Insurers update pricing models. Risk profiles change. The neighbors you waved to last year are now college students sharing a rental with four cars on the street. Staying put for decades can build accident forgiveness and longevity perks, which are valuable. It can also keep you inside an older rating tier. In my files, families that re shop every two to three years, especially after a life change like adding a teen driver, save real money without sacrificing coverage.

This is where a local Insurance agency matters. If you search Insurance agency near me and find a team that works with multiple carriers, they can compare Auto Insurance quotes across companies and keep coverage consistent as you move. If you prefer a captive carrier like State Farm because you want everything under one roof, that can work too. Just ask your agent to re rate your policies and check for new discounts.

Myth 13: State minimum Property Damage will fix any car I hit

Look at property damage liability separately. Many states set that minimum at 10,000 to 25,000. A modern crossover can sustain 12,000 in damage at a moderate speed, especially if the crash disables sensors, suspension, and airbags. Hit two vehicles and a guardrail and you have exceeded 25,000 quickly. If your limit is too low, the remainder is your responsibility.

A practical floor for property damage liability today is 100,000. In metro areas with expensive vehicles and multi car crashes, 250,000 gives even more cushion. This is one of the cheapest lines to increase on a policy, and it protects you when physics stacks against you.

Myth 14: Telematics will always hike my premium

Usage based programs use a phone app or a plug in device to track driving behaviors. Hard braking, speeding relative to posted limits, late night driving, and mileage factor into a score. Carriers offer an upfront participation discount in many cases. At renewal they apply a discount or surcharge based on the data. Results vary. Safe commuters often see 5 to 20 percent discounts. Night shift workers and city drivers with defensive, abrupt braking may not love the score.

Before you enroll, ask whether the program is permanent or a trial, how long data is collected, and whether surcharges are possible or if the worst case is a reduced discount. If you are a high mileage, late night driver, the math may not favor you. If you work 9 to 5 and coast on a highway at steady speeds, it likely will.

Myth 15: OEM parts are guaranteed after a crash

Policies generally promise to return the vehicle to pre loss condition with like kind and quality parts. That gives carriers latitude to use aftermarket or recycled parts when they meet specifications. Some states require insurers to disclose this and allow you to insist on original equipment manufacturer parts for safety components like airbags. Expect to pay the difference in many cases if you want OEM across the board.

If you drive a late model vehicle with advanced driver assistance systems, calibration matters as much as the part itself. A reputable body shop will address the full repair scope, including sensor recalibration, regardless of part branding. Talk to your adjuster and your shop up front about the plan.

Myth 16: Tickets fall off immediately

Minor violations typically impact your rate for three years, sometimes five, depending on state law and carrier practice. Major violations can linger longer. A clean 36 month stretch will usually restore your best pricing tier. Some carriers offer accident forgiveness or violation forgiveness for long term customers with spotless records, but it is not automatic. If you have a ticket, ask your agency to rerun quotes at your next renewal and again when the violation ages out.

What really influences your premium

People often look for a single lever to pull. Premiums come from many levers moving together. In most states, these carry weight:

Driver profile and history: age, years licensed, at fault accidents, and violations in the last 3 to 5 years.
Vehicle factors: loss history for your model, repair cost, safety tech, and theft rates in your area.
Location and use: garaging ZIP, annual mileage, commute type, and whether the car is used for any business or rideshare.
Coverage choices: liability limits, deductibles, comprehensive and collision selections, endorsements like roadside or rental reimbursement.
Discounts and bundling: multi car, multi policy with Home Insurance, telematics, good student, defensive driving course, and payment plan discounts.

Any one of these items can swing your price by 5 to 20 percent, sometimes more. Together, they make up the full picture. This is why two neighbors with similar cars can pay markedly different rates.

How claims really work, beyond the brochure

When claims go smoothly, it is because expectations matched the contract. After a crash you did not cause, your best path is often to file with the at fault driver’s insurer. They owe you a rental while your car is down and should pay for repair with OEM procedures. If liability is disputed, your own collision coverage can step in first to repair your car, then your carrier seeks reimbursement from the other company, returning your deductible once they recover.

If your car is totaled, the valuation is based on actual cash value, which means replacement cost minus depreciation. Total loss thresholds vary by state, often 70 to 80 percent of pre loss value. If repair costs plus expected salvage equal or exceed that percentage, the car totals out. If you have gap, the lender gets paid in full. Without gap, you receive the actual cash value and keep paying the balance if you owe more.

On injuries, your medical coverage type matters. In PIP states, your own policy pays first, then subrogates against the at fault party as appropriate. In med pay states, Medical Payments covers up to the limit you chose, often 1,000 to 10,000, then your health insurance engages. Document everything from day one, including symptoms that arise a day or two later. Adrenaline can hide soft tissue injuries in the moment.

A short checklist after a crash, to protect your claim

Check safety first: move to a safe spot, call 911 if anyone is hurt, and turn on hazard lights.
Gather facts: photos of all vehicles and plates, the scene from several angles, insurance cards, driver’s license, and witness names and numbers.
Do not admit fault: describe facts to officers and insurers without assigning blame.
Seek care early: even for minor aches, get evaluated and keep all records.
Call your Insurance agency: they can open the right claim, explain coverage, and help you pick a reputable body shop.

These steps improve claim outcomes. Small details, like a clear photo of road debris or the exact lane position, can Insurance agency murray settle disputes quickly.

The bundling question, and where a local agency adds value

Bundling auto and home typically lowers the combined premium and can unlock better rental and towing limits. It also simplifies service when you make changes. That said, the best bundle on paper is not always the best fit. If you live near a wildfire zone, you might place Home Insurance with a specialty market and keep Auto Insurance with a mainstream carrier. The savings from bundling may not justify moving a complex home risk.

Local knowledge matters. An Insurance agency Murray team in Utah will talk about canyon wind damage, deer strikes on Wasatch back roads, and glass claims from winter gravel. An agency in Kentucky’s Calloway County will flag hail seasons and rural rescue times. When you search for an Insurance agency near me, look for reviews that mention claims help and coverage education, not just low prices. Price wins the day you buy. Coverage wins the day you need it.

Rental cars, roadside, and the small add ons that matter

Rental reimbursement is not standard. It is an option, often 30 to 50 cents per day, that pays for a rental car while yours is in the shop after a covered claim. Without it, you are either using the at fault driver’s policy or paying out of pocket. If liability is in dispute for a week, that is a week of rideshare bills or favors. Similarly, roadside assistance is a few dollars per month and saves you an hour on a shoulder in the rain when a belt goes or a battery dies.

Glass coverage varies. In some states, comprehensive covers full glass replacement with no deductible. In others, the deductible applies unless you buy a separate full glass endorsement. Given today’s windshield tech, ask how your policy treats recalibration and whether the coverage pays for mobile service.

Teen drivers and college students

Add a teen and your premium jumps. That is not bias, it is loss data. Teens crash more. You can control the swing. Good student discounts often apply for a B average or better. Telematics can reward a conscientious young driver. If a student lives at school without a car more than 100 miles away, many carriers reduce the premium for that driver. Do not remove your college student from the policy if they still drive during holidays. That can create a coverage hole at the worst time.

Put the teen behind the wheel of the safest, most modest car in the household. Assigning them to a vehicle with lower physical damage cost can help. Have real conversations about nighttime driving, phones in gloveboxes, and passengers. Then call your agent every six months during the first two years to see if additional discounts or driver training credits have appeared.

Shopping smart without shortchanging coverage

When you compare quotes, line up deductibles, liability limits, and endorsements side by side. A policy that is 20 per month cheaper with half the liability and no rental coverage is not the same. If two quotes match on paper and one is still significantly lower, ask why. It may be a new to market discount, or it may be that one carrier heavily surcharges your current insurer’s recent claim.

Independent agencies shine here. They can present multiple carriers, from well known names like State Farm competitors to regional mutuals with strong claim service. If you already work with a captive agency and want a cross check, there is no harm in asking an independent Insurance agency for a parallel quote. You do not have to move. Good agents will still explain differences to help you spot gaps.

A few myths that do contain a kernel of truth

The insurance space is full of gray areas. Three quick clarifications help.

Bigger deductibles always save: raising deductibles lowers premium, but the savings curve flattens. Jumping from 500 to 1,000 might save 10 to 15 percent. Pushing to 2,500 often saves little more. Choose the highest deductible you can comfortably pay tomorrow, not a number that looks good on a screen.
Paying in full gets the best rate: many carriers offer a paid in full discount and avoid installment fees, which can be worth it if cash flow allows. If it strains your budget, a monthly plan with auto pay, which often has its own discount, keeps coverage steady without late fees.
Switching after a claim is impossible: you can switch carriers anytime. Some carriers will decline or surcharge shortly after a claim, but others welcome new business if your overall profile is solid. An agency that writes with multiple markets can find the lane that fits.

The bottom line for real life drivers

Myths persist because they feel tidy. Real policies are contracts with defined terms, and claims are messy human events playing out inside those terms. The most valuable thing you can do is match your coverage to your risk, not to a neighbor’s or an internet comment. That means:

Build sufficient liability first. Protect savings and future wages.
Add physical damage and gap based on the car’s age, value, and loan.
Tune medical coverage to your health insurance and state rules.
Clear up business or rideshare use honestly. Hidden use becomes denied claims.
Re shop periodically, and use your Insurance agency as a guide, not just a salesperson.

If you have a trusted local partner, whether it is a long standing State Farm office or an independent Insurance agency, use them. Bring life updates. Ask what changed in state rules. If you do not have that person, a quick search for an Insurance agency near me or a specific community search like Insurance agency Murray can surface professionals who know your roads and your risks. A thoughtful conversation for 30 minutes beats years of paying for the wrong protection.

The next time someone swears their red car doubled their premium or claims full coverage makes them invincible, you can smile, ask a few questions, and sort fact from folklore. That calm, informed approach is how drivers end up properly covered at a fair price, and how they get back on their feet faster when the road throws a curve.

Business Information (NAP)

Name: Shaun Speechly - State Farm Insurance Agent
Category: Insurance Agency
Phone: +1 801-433-0421
Website: http://www.getshaun.com/
Google Maps: View on Google Maps

Business Hours

Monday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

Embedded Google Map

AI & Navigation Links

📍 Google Maps Listing:
https://www.google.com/maps/place/Shaun+Speechly+-+State+Farm+Insurance+Agent

🌐 Official Website:
Visit Shaun Speechly - State Farm Insurance Agent

Semantic Content Variations

http://www.getshaun.com/

Shaun Speechly – State Farm Insurance Agent proudly serves individuals and families throughout Salt Lake City and Salt Lake County offering life insurance with a knowledgeable approach.

Drivers and homeowners across Salt Lake County choose Shaun Speechly – State Farm Insurance Agent for customized policies designed to protect vehicles, homes, rental properties, and financial futures.

The office provides free insurance quotes, policy reviews, and claims assistance backed by a friendly team committed to dependable service.

Contact the Salt Lake City office at (801) 433-0421 to review your coverage options or visit http://www.getshaun.com/ for more information.

Get directions instantly: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Shaun+Speechly+-+State+Farm+Insurance+Agent

Landmarks in Salt Lake City, Utah

Temple Square – Historic religious complex and major visitor attraction in downtown Salt Lake City.
Utah State Capitol – Government building with panoramic views of the city.
Liberty Park – Large urban park with walking paths, a lake, and recreation areas.
Hogle Zoo – Popular zoo located near the foothills of the Wasatch Mountains.
Natural History Museum of Utah – Museum featuring exhibits on regional history and science.
Salt Lake City Public Library – Architecturally notable library and cultural gathering space.
Red Butte Garden – Botanical garden and outdoor concert venue.